Bookanistas Review: Catching Jordan
Wednesday, February 22, 2012 at 11:45PM Hey y'all! Sorry for the radio silence on the blog this week. Did a little traveling with MAJOR HOTSAUCE and tried to fight the siren song of the Internet for a few days. But I'm back...and ready to talk about a wonderful, entertaining read!
This week I read CATCHING JORDAN, by Miranda Kenneally
From Goodreads:
What girl doesn't want to be surrounded by gorgeous jocks day in and day out? Jordan Woods isn't just surrounded by hot guys, though-she leads them as the captain and quarterback of her high school football team. They all see her as one of the guys, and that's just fine. As long as she gets her athletic scholarship to a powerhouse university. But now there's a new guy in town who threatens her starting position... suddenly she's hoping he'll see her as more than just a teammate.
My good friend Shari recommended this book on her blog, so I decided to check it out. It had been on my radar for a while: I remember reading Miranda's blog when she announced the sale and it stuck in my mind because I love football.
My Take
There were lots of things I absolutely loved about this book: the character development, the relationships between characters, the pacing, particularly of the second half of the book (I stayed up late to finish it, reading the entire second half in one sitting), the football...how fun to read a YA book about football! Geek moment, but I loved that I recognized all of the real football players the main character refers to.
But most of all I loved that this is a story about a girl distinguishing herself in a field/sport that is traditionally male only. As a teenager, I was definitely someone who felt held back sometimes by the fact that I was female. I often felt like I wanted to "prove them all wrong", that I was just as strong or as fast or as cool as the guys. It's one of the reasons short, little blond Buffy Summers appealed to me so much...I loved every single scene where an arrogant guy (or vampire) underestimated her...right before she kicked his butt. CATCHING JORDAN totally tapped into those feelings for me and even though I have never before played football or tried out for a male-dominated sport, I could still totally relate to the challenges Jordan faces in getting the respect she so desperately wants.
I have to admit the girl quarterback thing felt a little like wish fulfillment to me. I never fully bought into the idea of a high school team being so supportive of a female quarterback, even while I reveled in the protectiveness and respect Jordan's teammates feel for her. It all felt a little like a fairy tale...a story I *wanted* to believe but wasn't *quite* sure I did. Having said that, I think if I'd read this as a teenager, I would have been much less skeptical. In fact, I think I would have been 100% engaged with and inspired by this book. As I said...I was a girl who was reminded all too often that I couldn't do the same things as the boys. And, much like Buffy, Jordan totally kicks those boys' butts (at least on the football field!). :-)
Speaking of boys, there are some seriously cute ones here! I loved how the romantic entanglements reveal themselves throughout the story, beginning subtly and building into some really compelling conflict. There were many sweet, romantic moments that had me swooning.
Caveat
There was one thing in the book that rubbed me the wrong way. It wasn't a dealbreaker for me - I obviously loved the book - but it would be dishonest not to mention that the scene with Jordan's first kiss and its aftermath bothered me. I didn't have any issues with the casual sex in the book or the promiscuity of the characters in general (or rather, the fact that that was an element in the book - I'm not advocating sleeping around! ;-))...but I remember my very first kiss. And I just can't imagine anyone going from that fraught, intense, exciting, insecure, emotional moment...straight to where Jordan went. In my opinion her character development to that point didn't support what happened, and the moment was glossed over way too casually. Maybe it's because I related to so much of Jordan's character, her insecurities and desire for respect, that that moment didn't work for me. We all project ourselves into what we read, so I fully acknowledge this probably had more to do with who I am as a reader than any fault in the story.
Final Thoughts
In conclusion, I highly recommend CATCHING JORDAN! Like Kody Keplinger's DUFF, I'd say it's most appropriate for older YA readers, given the swearing and sex, but I think any girl, young or old(er), who has ever been patronized or not taken seriously because of her gender, will love Jordan and this book. :-)
Oh, and totally unrelated sidenote...I got bangs! ;-) (sorry for the pink "mood lighting"!)

~~
Now, check out what the rest of the Bookanistas have been up to!
Christine Fonseca interviews author L.K. Gardner-Griffie
Corrine Jackson announces Change Write Now: Round 2 signups are open
Carolina Valdez Miller adores UNDER THE NEVER SKY - with giveaway
Jen Hayley has a passion for PARTIALS
Jessica Love shares some TIME BETWEEN US cover talk
Tracy Banghart jumps for CATCHING JORDAN
Stasia Ward Kehoe contemplates middle grade series
LiLa Roecker is enthralled with THE NIGHT CIRCUS
Shelli Johannes-Wells visits with author Elle Strauss
Tracy |
2 Comments |
The Bookanistas 









